secare: (you're going nowhere by the mile。)
ʏᴜᴋɪ(ɴᴇ) ♦ 「雪音」 ([personal profile] secare) wrote in [community profile] retrospec2018-01-22 03:28 pm

a day in the life

Yukine Matsuoka
1/22 near Tisse
Okay. Settle an argument for me because SOMEONE has messed up taste.

Would you consider this to be a love song?

Radiohead - Creep

Just don't ask me why.

ETA: what is your favourite love song?
fiddlestick: (stop yelling heals you have regen on)

curse work

[personal profile] fiddlestick 2018-01-23 01:50 am (UTC)(link)
No!
You just seem to have a very narrow view of love songs.


[So. Yes.]

Well there's lots of romantic ones!
But sometimes it's refreshing to hear a fresh perspective on it.
fiddlestick: (Dawwwww)

[personal profile] fiddlestick 2018-01-23 02:30 am (UTC)(link)
Hahaha, sure!
I'm always happy to hear new music!
fiddlestick: (elliot092)

[personal profile] fiddlestick 2018-01-23 05:33 pm (UTC)(link)
[A pause as he listens to it twice]

Well it's a pretty melody.
I like the beat.
And they work well as a duet, their voices keep in perfect harmony.
It's a song I'd have on in the background, sure, because it is good for easy listening.

But there's no passion to it.
Love's not supposed to be easy.
They're so focused on staying in harmony with one another, there's barely any emotion.
I have trouble connecting to anything they're singing on an emotional level other than "oh it sounds nice".
They could've written this about their lost phone.
fiddlestick: (elliot093)

1/2

[personal profile] fiddlestick 2018-01-24 03:12 pm (UTC)(link)
This isn't a competition Yukine.
I'm not comparing the two, and I said I liked stuff about the song.
And I never said Creep is perfect, I know I wouldn't play it at a wedding.

But Creep has its own uses as a song about love, it's a classic for a reason.
Imagine if someone's been rejected by someone they like, or maybe they did something they're not proud of because of their feelings.
People usually feel like crap in those situations, and they might have feelings that aren't pretty.
Creep acknowledges those ugly feelings, and helps the listener acknowledge them too.
And once you're able to acknowledge them, you can address them and work them out
Which is much better than denying they exist and letting them fester.

I mean, think about the movie we watched.
To impress her, he nearly compromised his own values about bullfighting
But he couldn't even go through with it, and ended up causing humiliation for himself and his family in front of the whole town.
Which is a HUGE deal in Mexican culture
And then from his viewpoint, it was all in vain because she left with the other guy
A guy that's been praised as the town hero for years, while he never got that kind of praise.
We know she doesn't like that guy, but he doesn't know that.
No wonder he was feeling pretty crappy about himself, like he was pathetic for even trying.
So he needed a moment to vent those ugly feelings about himself, and Creep was a fine choice for that.
And once he did that, he could work up the strength to sing his feelings to her with the actual love song.

So maybe give Creep a break, please?
fiddlestick: (youre dumb af)

[personal profile] fiddlestick 2018-01-24 03:15 pm (UTC)(link)
[But he'll click on the song]

Oh! I know this song!
I used to sing it all the time!
Nice choice.
fiddlestick: (jaw scratch)

[personal profile] fiddlestick 2018-02-01 06:00 am (UTC)(link)
Haha guess I did go on and on.
Sorry about that.
fiddlestick: (fuq what)

[personal profile] fiddlestick 2018-02-04 01:29 am (UTC)(link)
What?
You don't think it's weird?
fiddlestick: (elliot093)

[personal profile] fiddlestick 2018-02-05 05:25 am (UTC)(link)
Idk...

People sometimes think I'm weird for how much I get into music.
fiddlestick: (ok but before murder how bout talk?)

[personal profile] fiddlestick 2018-02-12 10:21 pm (UTC)(link)
Aww
Thanks Yukine.
You're sweet.
fiddlestick: (headscratch)

[personal profile] fiddlestick 2018-02-12 10:27 pm (UTC)(link)
[NOPE YOU'RE SWEET]

Heehee
I'll try my best not to.